My family has been living on Maui for over twenty years, and I’ve been visiting the island for long lengths of time — so much so that it’s become my second home. Over the years I’ve narrowed down my favorite Maui restaurants… these are the places that I hit up no matter if I’m there for one week or one month. These places are no ka oi and are must-visits on your Maui vacation:
1. The Mill House — Wailuku
Everything’s coming up Mill House! I don’t know what I love more about this place: The view or the food. Everything we ate at The Mill House was awesome — from their entrees to their side of lentils — and everything we didn’t eat and just watched go buy looked awesome! We were in Maui culinary heaven.
- Chicken bao buns
- Taro leaf risotto
2. Monkeypod — Wailea and Ka’anapali
You can seriously bring anyone to Monkeypod and they’d rave about it. I was introduced to it by a vegan friend, but it’s not even close to a vegan restaurant! Mike and I go here all the time, and everything we’ve tried is stellar.
Oh and you should definitely order their Mai Tais topped with honey lilikoi foam!
3. Mama’s Fish House — Paia
This is definitely one of Maui’s top restaurants, if not THEE top restaurant. It’s pricey, so we mostly make it a lunch thing, because the views are stunning during the day.
But no matter when you go, you should get:
- Beef Polynesian — spicy seared beef tenderloin in a grilled papaya
- Mahimahi — stuffed with lobster and crab and baked in a macadamia nut crust
- AND EVERY SINGLE DESSERT! (The “Black Pearl” is especially amazing.
4. Flatbread Company — Paia
Flatbread is often my first meal on Maui and my last, and also peppered sporadically throughout my time on the island. It’s my all time favorite pizza of my life. And they make a good salad too. That’s because all their ingredients are local and fresh AF, and their pizzas are wood-fired right in front of you.
- The Organic Salad — ask if they have avocado to add to it.
- Any of their pizzas.
5. Braddah Hutts BBQ Grill (food truck) — Hana
Braddah Hutts BBQ is a food truck right off the road to Hana. It’s “Island Style Barbeque” and it’s some of the best food we’ve ever had on the island.
- Mahi tacos
- BBQ ribs
6. Kihei Caffe — Kihei
Kihei Caffe is expensive, with an annoyingly long line, and it closes early, and they often mess up orders. All these things should make me hate this place… BUT I DO NOT. I love it. I miss it. I follow it on Instagram and drool over their amazing breakfast creations every dang day. It’s worth the money and the wait.
- Pancakes (but they’re a HUGE order, so make sure to have someone to split them with)
- Loco Moco
7. South Maui Fish Company (food truck) — Kihei
If you like your poke in the California, healthy-style, stay away. If you like it smothered in delicious sauce and served with the best coleslaw you’ve ever had (pineapple coconut milk slaw is NO KA OI!) then head to the South Maui Fish Company food truck when it opens at 11am. Because they only use freshly caught fish, and only have a limited amount, so they’ll sell out, and you’ll be sad.
8. Star Noodle — Lahaina
This is the place that foodies rave to other foodies about. And for good reason. Star Noodle has amazing fresh house made noodles and Asian specialties plus a full sake bar.
9. Da Kitchen — Kahului and Kihei
Everyone loves Da Kitchen — from locals to tourists — and no one cares that it’s in a shopping center off a busy road near the airport. One view of their menu and you won’t care that there’s no view to speak of. They specialize in plate lunches, but they also have an extended special menu that’ll make your head spin with all their awesome choices.
- The deep-fried Spam musubi
- A plate lunch of some kind
10. Fabiani’s — Kihei
Full disclosure: A friend of the family owns Fabiani’s. Also full disclosure: It doesn’t freaking matter because I’d eat at this place every day even if I didn’t know anyone who worked there. We’re hashtag blessed to live close to this place, which means we’ve eaten there a lot, and we’re always happy. And you should keep going back too because Fabiani changed the pizza specials all the time, and they’re always great.
Plus you should snag a pastry (I love the croissants) to take home for breakfast on the beach the next day!
11. Tin Roof — Wailuku
I really hope Tin Roof signals a wonderful trend for gourmet mom and pops on Maui. Set in a strip mall off of one of Maui’s most unimpressive roads (the one that takes you two and from the airport), near a bunch of gas stations, is one of the best places to eat on Maui. But it’s so small you’ll probably have to get your bowls to go.
- The Mochiko bowl: Chicken thighs marinated overnight in ginger sake shoyu, covered in a sweet mochiko batter, then fried twice, topped with housemade su-miso sauce & gochujang aioli, & mochi crunch dime bag mix.
- Whatever their poke bowl is that day.
12. Ferraro’s at the Four Seasons — Wailea
This place never disappoints, and, because it’s a Four Seasons, they’ll go out of their way to make you happy. I suggest that you sit at the bar — the view is the best from up there — and have a Lahaina Lemonade with whatever you order.
Which probably should be one of these things:
- Chicken Quesadillas — Topped with Black Bean Pico de Gallo and Avocado
- Ahi poke pizza — yeah, it’s a thing, and it’s awesome!
- Stir Fry
Enough people have raved about this place to me that I had to drive to Makawao to check out Hali’imaile General Store. It closes between lunch and dinner, and we just made it in time. But no matter when you go, there will be a wait, because this place is fantastic.
You should definitely add these to your order:
- French fries — IMHO they’re the best on the island.
- Duck quesadillas
- Pineapple upside down cake with vanilla ice cream — voted best dessert on the island for a reason!
- Pita Paradise in Wailea — — Their veggie platter is my happy place any time of the day
- Merriman’s in Kapalua — Try to snag a table during sunset, otherwise there’s ZERO view at night.
- Five Palms — it has one of the best views on Maui and one of the best happy hours too.
- Morimoto and Ka’ana Kitchen at the Andaz — Morimoto is widely loved. And Ka’ana Kitchen has a fried chicken dish that’s a great variation on a theme of chicken and waffles.
- The Market in Wailea — Great healthy food options.
- The Dog and Duck in Kihei– my friend owns this pub, and it’s a fun place to drink, watch games, and have yummy pub fare.
- Lappert’s — They have amazing coffee ice cream.
Or choose a Maui restaurant by photo!:
What are you favorite Maui restaurants or things to eat on the island?